Score: 10

"I love dad"

submission: Dad's at Work

date: July 9, 2007

Dad is pure animated goodness!

Score: 8

"Great animation"

submission: Uberkid's Revenge

date: May 5, 2007

The animation depicted in this submission is fantastic. Although the style did not pull me in, that is personal, and does not change the fact that this was a great short that was full of energy. Nice work.

Score: 10

"Smooth Animation"

submission: Pico's Time Tank

date: May 5, 2007

A lot of nice animation in this submission. Very smooth, well done, lots of angles and scene changes, different styles of art/animation used... this was a real treat to see and a shame that it was not rated as number 1 considering how much more professional this submission felt.

Score: 8

"Is great where it counts..."

submission: E.M.O.

date: February 27, 2007

This is a great flash. It definitely sums up the emos very well.

Score: 8

"Great Production Values"

submission: "The Golden Mushroom"

date: July 27, 2006

From voice work to animation quality, this was a well put together piece. The voice actors all had distinct, quality sounding voices, and didn't sound all too forced. The graphics... well they're sprites, so what can we really say about sprites? Not much, but I'm not saying I don't like sprite movies... just, they're sprites. The writing, it was pretty good and kept you entertained. Anyway, it was a great movie, and I have it favorited both author and submission style.

My personal favorite was when Mario is running and just "La-la-ing" the Mario background music.

Suggestion: With a movie of this length, it would be good to have a DVD-esque interface. You know, pause, play at least. Even though I can right click... anyway... Great movie!

Score: 9

"Great Short"

submission: Imaginary Friend

date: July 25, 2006

This was a very nicely done, emotional short, animated perfectly to the narraration song. The graphics themselves lacked much character, but fit the piece nicely. The song is fitting, and it was really well executed. Good job!

Score: 9

"Pretty Damn Funny"

submission: super marrio parodies

date: June 9, 2006

Funny sense of humor. I think the people confused only see this at face value. I thought it was funny shit.

Score: 10

"Creative and well executed"

submission: Animator vs. Animation

date: June 7, 2006

The animation you displayed here was phenomenal. A great piece of work that everyone on NG should see. Everyone here from the great to the lowliest could appreciate the cleverness and quality of this animation. It was a very good short that stayed interesting from beginning to end. Good work man.

Score: 9

"Favorited It"

submission: HAMU

date: April 7, 2006

This is a good game, I like the style and it remains true to the original breakout, while doing some things that make it a unique twist to the original. The downsides to it are lack of power-ups and the musical loop gets annoying after awhile with no option to mute the music. If you could mute the music, but leave the sound effects that would be a definite improvement in my mind. But that is not a big deal. The gameplay is great, and fun. Good work.

Score: 5

"If I were your g/f..."

submission: Won't You Be My Valentine

date: February 14, 2006

...I'd question your sexuality.

This was a... umm... "unique" Valentine, most certainly. It scared me, I will not lie. Giant dancing rotoscoped hearts and angels dancing about that remind me of a certain animated .gif we've all seen at one point or another are combined with the typical Valentine's Day colours to create the recipies to what's sure to be life ruining trauma to all aged 60 and younger.

I gave it a 3/5 because it's not horrible; it's just frightening!